I was saddened to hear the news of the death of Anne McCaffrey. She’s one of the authors I grew up with, and last night (no doubt along with many others) I reached for ‘Dragonflight’ to begin a memorial re-read.
I did the same earlier this year, following the death of Diana Wynne Jones. I re-read many favourites, and discovered some of her books for the first time. As part of this, I read ‘Archer’s Goon’ for (what I thought was) the first time.
It wasn’t the first time. I’d forgotten almost everything about the book, but the names prompted some stirrings in the back of my memory, little snippets of deja-lu. The line ‘Dillian farms law and order’ hit me like a punch to the gut. Of course she did. She couldn’t possibly do anything else. I knew this; I’d always known it.
I’ve re-read many half (or totally) forgotten books before, but I’d never had such a visceral, physical reaction. The whole book was like a series of body-blows. It was exhausting and exhilerating, and all the while things hung at the back of my mind, emerging fully-formed a page or two before the denouement in the text.
So I searched my shelves, expecting to find a battered old copy tucked away. I found it quite odd that I could remember nothing about the physicality of the book – no memory of cover art, or spine on my neatly alphabetised shelves. It must have been a library book.
But how will I know? I envy the current and future generations of library users. They can electronically access their borrowing record. They can see (or will be able to see) what they were reading when they were 7, 8, 9, 19, 29. They can jog their memory, or escape into the past.
Catalogue permitting, anyway… I’ve just checked my borrowing history on the Manchester Libraries catalogue. After all, they’ve been online for a while – surely I can go back a few years down memory lane, at least? Not so! I can go back a year at most, and there’s only a list of loans and reservations. No loan dates. Manchester Uni is much better – I can see my loans going right back to when my card was issued in 2006, and see issue and return dates for all items. So why not for Manchester Libraries? They must have the data – why aren’t they letting me use it? It’s my data.
We talk about making the most of the data that we have, but we also have to remember to allow users to make the most of it, too. For nearly three years, I’ve been recording every book I read (I predict 2 reactions to this: ‘that’s so sad!’ and ‘hey, I’ve been doing that for years!’), and I’d love to use my library data to help me go back further, and fill in some of the gaps. I want my library to help me record and celebrate my love of reading.
And boy, do I love reading. There’s that phrase which chases us around the libinfosphere, a variant on:
‘You don’t become a librarian because you like books.’
Well, actually, many of us do. Let’s be more accurate:
‘You don’t become a good librarian because you just like books.’
You become -and stay – a good librarian by liking other things, too. You like people; computers; metadata; gin. You have a passion for teaching or research. You see the void which exists between a person and the information they need, and you have to fill it.
Sometimes, that void is filled by books. Sometimes it’s filled by information about books. Don’t put barriers in the way of either of them. Don’t make future generations crawl around in the electronic equivalent of a dusty old storage room, hunting through obsolete data formats. Don’t make them have to put in a request.
I have a vision, my friends. A vision of a future in which no-one will have to wonder when they first read ‘Archer’s Goon’. And we can make it happen.

10 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 23, 2011 at 5:59 pm
Laura Steel (@PalelyLaura)
I fall into the latter camp – I’ve kept a reading diary since my 18th birthday, only these days I have an Access database too so I can easily see which books I’ve read! I think it would be a brilliant idea to be able to access your past lending record. I wonder how many people borrow a great book from the library and then forget title and author so they can’t find it again?
As a slight aside I’ve never read anything by Anne McCaffrey and had never previously heard of any of her books – judging by the reaction on Twitter it sounds like I’m missing out.
November 23, 2011 at 6:53 pm
bethan
wow, I’m impressed by the foresight and organisation of your reading diary and database! Mine’s just on s google docs spreadsheet… And yes, you should definitely try Anne McCaffrey! The Pern series is fantastic, but if you don’t like dragons, the Tower and Hive and the Crystal Singer series are faves of mine too
November 24, 2011 at 2:28 pm
woodsiegirl
I also fall into the latter camp – I’ve been keeping a record of all the books I read for the past few years, using LibraryThing. Weird? No, of course not, who would say such a thing..? :s
I would love to be able to get data from all my book loans from all the libraries I am or have been a member of (that’s about 8 different local authorities, at present!) Sadly, probably not possible. I know at Newham Libraries I used to be able to see my borrowing history – will have to dig out my library card later, log in and see if it’s still there. Sadly my current main library – Kirkless libraries – doesn’t seem to show my borrowing history at all
I wonder, if this data was routinely made available, would it cut down on the “I borrowed it from here 8 years ago, it had a red cover, can you find it for me?” type requests at the issue desk!
November 24, 2011 at 8:38 pm
bethan
I guess I shouldn’t be surprised at how many librarians are closet reading-record-keepers! I agree, it would be lovely if we could combine information from all of the local authorities – have one borrower record for you, wherever you are in the UK. I know people have been working towards a unified library card – I really hope it happens!
November 27, 2011 at 11:40 pm
Samantha Halford (@samanthahalf)
Is it possible that you watched it on TV? There was a great series of it on in the early 90s, as you can see from the haircuts in this video: Archer’s Goon
December 5, 2011 at 2:17 pm
bethan
nope, doesn’t ring any bells! But looks like a good adaptation – might have to while away some time on youtube with that – if I can get past the 90s fashion
December 1, 2011 at 1:29 pm
Annie
I wonder whether the problem is actually the LMS? The amount of borrowing data available from them can vary quite a lot – so is this a question of pushing LMS providers to include this type of feature, rather than libraries to provide access?
December 5, 2011 at 2:21 pm
bethan
You’re right, of course – librarians should be asking LMS providers to make this functionality available. But we, as patrons, can’t approach LMS suppliers ourselves – it’s the libraries, with the buying power (ok, exactly how much power, where is debatable!) that need to be pushing for it. So yes, as librarians, talk to your LMS supplier – but as a library user, talk to your library
January 5, 2012 at 6:48 pm
trgllylibrarian
It could be really helpful if LMSs could provide the data in a format that can be linked with patron accounts on Library Thing or Goodreads. I know that Goodreads can import books, ratings, and reviews from a .csv file. When I moved my book records from LivingSocial Books (which no longer exists) to Goodreads, I downloaded two .csv files (one for book ratings and one for book reviews) with five columns each: title, author, ISBN, “status” (either “rating” or “review”), and rating/review. I bet it wouldn’t be that hard to keep that information in an LMS and make it exportable. You would have to add the information about the dates the book was read. I don’t know whether Goodreads can import that…
January 6, 2012 at 12:06 pm
bethan
What a great idea! Not just letting you have your data, but giving it to you in a format you can easily reuse elsewhere. And I’m sure if enough people on Goodreads etc wanted a ‘date read’ filed added, they could do that!